Is Miliband giving activists a role on the inside?
“… The old diplomacy was defined by a world of limited information. It was a veritable secret garden of negotiations. And secret negotiation still matters. But we live in a world where the views of a Pashtun herdsman, and the conflict he faces between illegal opium production and legal farming, holds the fate of a critical country in the balance. So the new diplomacy is public as well as private, mass as well as elite, real-time as well as deliberative. And that needs to be reflected in the way we do our business.”
- excerpt from David Miliband’s first speech as Foreign Secretary, speaking to The New Diplomacy (text on FCO site, spotty video on YouTube, and webcast on avaaz.org)
Which signals a greater commitment to online communities and a frank conversation with the general public?
- a blog, or
- co-hosting your first major policy speech with an international and online activist organization?
David Miliband, the British Cabinet Minister formerly known online for his personal blog posts as DEFRA Minister, has been promoted to the post of Foreign Secretary. No new blog yet, but the signs are encouraging.
In fact, Miliband’s first major policy speech was co-hosted by avaaz.org - a relatively new international and online activist organization. In addition to the vague but reassuring words in his speech about non-traditional influences on diplomacy and foreign policy priorities. the new Foreign Secretary fielded some questions submitted online by avaaz’ members.
“…At the end we handed David Miliband his own Book of Global Public Opinion, with all our members’ thousands of questions and pieces of advice, warning and encouragement. Clarion calls for an ethical foreign policy, a new global climate treaty, all-party negotiations and ending occupation in the Middle East, the protection of human rights and decisive action on poverty. I hope he’s reading it now.” (Paul Hilder, in HuffPost)
The talk is even being walked on the Foreign and Commonwealth Office website.
The FCO is encouraging Britons to “Have Their Say” about the speech and the FCO’s priorities. Unfortunately, the system seems to consist of an HTML form, a formal review process once submitted, and then a static compilation of comments.
The three themes under this section have links to reddit, del.icio.us and digg - but none of the other pages on the FCO site seem to have them.
It’s a first step, isn’t it?
The larger question remains how Miliband’s past experience with online comment and activism will be reflected in the polices and practices developed by the FCO.
Will public diplomacy really change as a result? Or will the process be more incremental, simply as a result of institutional inertia and the greater challenge of shifting the course of a large foreign policy apparatus.
July 25th, 2007 16:25
We shouldn’t be at all surprised to see Miliband approaching things this way - especially in the context of the recent Mayo/Steinberg report which called on departments to use existing third-party networks, rather than trying to build their own. Besides, I don’t think diplomacy is ready for a blogging Foreign Secretary; and Avaaz.org is a safe partner for a supposed Blairite, given its links back to MoveOn.org.
Yes, the digg/delicious/reddit buttons are a new addition, but so far they haven’t been too effective: only two individuals seem to have used them, and I suspect they’re both FCO staffers.
I’ve met with the FCO web team in the recent past; unless they were bluffing, I don’t think they had particular plans for something like this. But then again, I don’t think they were expecting to get Miliband in the reshuffle.
July 26th, 2007 10:15
Thanks, Simon. The US State Department seems to be pulling ahead in some respects, doesn’t it?